Merry Edwards Pinot Noir RR - 2018 - Merry Edwards Winery
Alcoholic content: 14.50 %
yr. 2019 Wine Enthusiast:
95 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2019 on 01.11.2021 with 95 of 100 points.
"A hint of stemmy earthiness leads the way to a luxurious, expansive and velvety palate. The acidity is edgy and fresh, lifting the savory and floral components over a rich, complex berry core. Virginie Boone"
yr. 2018 Wine Enthusiast:
94 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2018 on 01.12.2020 with 94 of 100 points.
"Supple in tannin and earthy in black tea, this appellation wine is delicious, with depth and freshness. Lively acidity boosts a core of dark cherry, pomegranate and cherry--the fruit well contrasted in nutmeg and clove. Virginie Boone"
yr. 2018 Vinum Wine Magazine:
17 of 20 Points.
"Vinum Wine Magazine" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2018 on 01.05.2020 with 17 of 20 points.
"Dunkles Rubinrot. In der Nase Brombeeren, Blaubeeren, der Holzeinfluss ist deutlich. Am Gaumen kommt zur Frucht Anis, wieder das getoastete Holz. Ganz weit hinten sind da auch ein paar Blüten, Veilchen. Klar strukturiert, vitale, lebhafte Säure trifft auf seidiges, deutlich schmeckbares Tannin. Im Abgang kommt die sortentypische Pfeffernote, wie ein kleiner Weckruf. Gewinnt mit jeder Minute im Glas, braucht definitiv noch Zeit."
yr. 2017 Wine Enthusiast:
93 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2017 on 01.12.2019 with 93 of 100 points.
"This wine is tangy and fresh, with lively acidity carrying flavors of red cherry, cranberry and blueberry. Lifted tones of rose and white pepper counteract a full-bodied richness and complements the lushness of the fruit. Virginie Boone"
yr. 2016 Wine Enthusiast:
91 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2016 on 01.12.2018 with 91 of 100 points.
"Herbal and forested in savory elements like rose petal and black tea, this is a gorgeously rich and round red wine, a true showcase of the appellation and sure to please a crowd. Red and black cherry are met by wild strawberry and lush waves of depth. Virginie Boone"
yr. 2015 Wine Enthusiast:
94 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2015 on 01.01.2018 with 94 of 100 points.
"Made from grapes sourced from several sites across the appellation, this shows deft winemaking skill in its velvety, gritty texture and beautiful aromas and flavors of cured meat, rose petal and Asian five spice. Bright acidity lifts the tones of cranberry, rhubarb and mushroom earthiness, with a touch of crushed stone."
yr. 2014 Wine Enthusiast:
93 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2014 on 01.01.2017 with 93 of 100 points.
"A blend from several of the producer's finest vineyards, including Georganne, Flax, Olivet Lane and Klopp, this offers complex notes of smoky lavender and licorice. Velvety texture underlies mouth-coating flavors of blackberry jam, pomegranate and cardamom, finishing tartly in acidity."
yr. 2013 Wine Enthusiast:
95 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2013 on 01.01.2016 with 95 of 100 points.
"The producer's larger-production offering, this in no way suffers from not having a vineyard designated. Instead, it shows the prowess of blending, delivering a big, bold style with elegance and grace. Tangy cranberry and orange rind wrap themselves around powerful acidity and a silky body, finishing with notes of earth and cardamom."
yr. 2014 Falstaff:
92 of 100 Points.
"Falstaff" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2014 on 01.01.2016 with 92 of 100 points.
"Dunkles Rubingranat, violette Reflexe, breitere Randaufhellung. Zart nach Dörrpflaumen, schwarze Kirschen, mineralisch, feine Holznuancen. Komplex, stoffig, extraktsüß, präsente, extraktsüße Tannine, gutes Reifepotenzial."
yr. 2012 Wine Enthusiast:
90 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2012 on 01.01.2015 with 90 of 100 points.
"Sourced from six different vineyards, this is a broadly pleasing wine, fruity in blackberry and raspberry that veers even into cranberry and cassis territory without getting bogged down. Substantial and lush, it's tightly woven in tannin and savory herb, ready to open itself over time. Patience will reward with more exotic interweavings of vanilla-cola and tea."
yr. 2011 Wine Enthusiast:
92 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2011 on 01.01.2014 with 92 of 100 points.
"Okay, so this is "only" Merry Edwards' regional blend. But don't dismiss it. Made from her greatest vineyards, including Flax, Meredith Estate and Coopersmith, it shows the linearity and elegance of her 2011s, without perhaps quite the concentation of the single-vineyard wines. Dry, tannic and brisk in acidity, the flavors are classic cool-climate rhubarbs, pomegranates, blackberry tea, dried herbs and cocoa. Give it up until 2020 to come around."
yr. 2010 Wine Enthusiast:
91 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2010 on 01.01.2013 with 91 of 100 points.
"Most Pinot Noirs would kill to have this depth of flavor. Although it's the winery's most basic, non-vineyard-designated Pinot, it's a fantastic wine, rich, mellow and delicious. Offers wave after wave of cherries, currants, cola, pomegranates and persimmons that are as sweet as jam, yet the finish is thoroughly dry. The wine is a masterful blend of seven vineyards. Drink now-2014."
yr. 2009 Wine Enthusiast:
93 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2009 on 01.01.2012 with 93 of 100 points.
"Merry Edwards doesn't just slap this regional blend together. This is a combination of her best vineyards. It's a wonderful wine, dry, balanced and deep in berry, spice, cola and earthy flavors. In many ways, it's the consummate Russian River Valley Pinot Noir. Drink now-2015."
yr. 2007 Wine Enthusiast:
92 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2007 on 01.07.2011 with 92 of 100 points.
"Marked by fresh, sleek acidity and firm, dusty tannins, this is a Pinot to stash in the cellar for a while. It's just too tough and hard now. Give it 4-6 years to soften, and let the black cherries, red currants and cola mesh with the oak and transform with the magic of bottle age."
yr. 2008 Wine Enthusiast:
93 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2008 on 01.01.2011 with 93 of 100 points.
"A blend of seven vineyards scattered across the valley, this is a full-bodied, ripe Pinot Noir whose tannins suggest cellaring. Thoroughly dry, it shows deep notes of blackberries, black cherries, clove and pepper spice and smoky, vanilla-scented sandalwood. Feels elegant. Give it until 2013, at least."
yr. 2006 Wine Enthusiast:
86 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2006 on 01.01.2009 with 86 of 100 points.
"Dry and elegant. Crisp acidity and fine tannins provide a firm structure, with just the right touch of oak. The cherry, currant and pomegranate fruit flavors have a touch of green mintiness that distracts. Drink now."
yr. 2005 Wine Enthusiast:
86 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2005 on 01.01.2008 with 86 of 100 points.
"A bit disappointing. Starts off with an exciting blast of cherry, cola, pomegranate and smoky vanilla aromas, but turns thin in the mouth, with only modest cherry and tamari flavors."
yr. 2004 Wine Enthusiast:
87 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2004 on 01.01.2007 with 87 of 100 points.
"Without the bright acidity of Merry's '04 Sonoma Coast Pinot, this is a less interesting wine. It has rich flavors of cola, cherries, plums and earth, but is a little on the soft side. In a hot vintage like 2004, the cooler Coast does better than the warmer Russian River. And vice versa in a cool year. Drink now."
yr. 2002 Wine Enthusiast:
86 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2002 on 01.01.2005 with 86 of 100 points.
"This is an easy, all-purpose Pinot despite some fairly hefty tannins. It glides over the tongue carrying cola, cherry, rhubarb, heirloom tomato and smoky flavors, and finishes dry."
yr. 2001 Wine Enthusiast:
87 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2001 on 01.01.2004 with 87 of 100 points.
"A lovely Pinot that rises above everyday status to achieve real depth and complexity, although it's not on a par with Merry's single-vineyard releases. It's light and silky, with spicy flavors of cherries, rhubarb, tea, vanilla and toast."
yr. 2000 Wine Enthusiast:
93 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2000 on 01.01.2003 with 93 of 100 points.
"Big Pinot, opening with a blast of black cherries, truffle, smoke, new kid leather and a thousand other scents. Rich, dense and fruity--a delight packed with pure cherry flavors. Yet it feels light as a feather, soft as silk. Editors' Choice. --S.H."
yr. 2020 Wine Spectator:
92 of 100 Points.
"Wine Spectator" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2020 on 01.09.2022 with 92 of 100 points.
yr. 2018 Wine Spectator:
88 of 100 Points.
"Wine Spectator" has rated the wine "Merry Edwards Pinot Noir" from the vintage 2018 on 01.10.2020 with 88 of 100 points.
